The U.S. organ transplant system is now recommending that surgeons slit the blood vessels supplying organ donors’ brains as a safety measure to keep the donors from waking up when doctors resuscitate the remainder of their bodies for organ procurement.
The new guidelines apply to a type of organ retrieval known as Normothermic Regional Perfusion (NRP). NRP organ donors are not brain dead, but they either have a poor prognosis or have decided that their quality of life is unacceptable. Their deaths are planned to occur in such a way as to allow them to donate their organs.
The NRP process begins by withdrawing medical support and letting the donor’s heart stop. At this point, death is declared under the Uniform Determination of Death Act’s (UDDA) circulatory-respiratory standard: the irreversible cessation of circulatory and respiratory functions.
But because waiting for the heart to stop beating is often a slow process, the organs can begin to degrade from a lack of oxygen. This hypoxic interval can make organs like the heart unsuitable for transplantation. If these organs could somehow be resuscitated, the number of transplantable organs could be increased. But if blood flow to the brain should occur during this resuscitation, the patient might wake up.
Therefore, in order to procure a donor heart, NRP surgery traditionally begins with clamping off the blood flow to the patient’s brain. This is meant to make the patient intentionally brain dead and prevent them from waking up when the rest of the body is resuscitated. Also, by clamping the arteries that feed the brain, the legal category of death switches to the UDDA’s neurologic standard: the irreversible cessation of all functions of the entire brain including the brain stem. This way, doctors are legally covered when the person is resuscitated from the neck down and their heart starts beating again.
NRP has always been ethically and legally problematic — because NRP donors are not actually dead. The NRP technique plays fast and loose with the legal definitions of death under the UDDA. First, death is declared as the IRREVERSIBLE cessation of circulatory and respiratory functions. But because doctors are planning to restart the heart (showing that its cessation was not actually irreversible after all), they clamp the arteries to the brain in order to make the person brain dead on purpose. The American College of Physicians, the world’s largest specialty medical organization, recommended in 2021 that the practice of NRP be paused, as “the burden of proof regarding the ethical and legal propriety of this practice has not been met.”
University of Colorado bioethicist Matthew DeCamp, MD, Ph.D. and colleagues wrote in 2022 that NRP patients are not actually dead: “Restarting circulation reverses what was just declared to be the irreversible cessation of circulatory and respiratory function. It is no defense to suggest that the patient was already dead when the action negates the conditions upon which the determination was made.”
In an article published by The American Journal of Bioethics, Lauris Kaldjian, MD, Ph.D., director of the bioethics and humanities program at the University of Iowa Carver College of Medicine, wrote: “NRP represents a technologically elaborate attempt to refashion definitions of death to maximize the number and quality of transplanted organs. It both depends on and violates the circulatory definition of death and arguably employs iatrogenic (doctor-induced) brain death.”
Then in 2024, a whistleblower transplant surgeon, Dr. Claire Morgan, filed complaints with federal regulators and the national transplant network saying that the blood flow to the brain in NRP donors is NOT always completely clamped off. This means that these patients could potentially be aware and experiencing pain during the removal of their organs.
Dr. Morgan’s concerns were not abstract: They arose from multiple cases in her own experience in which she personally witnessed surgery being performed on NRP patients whose brain blood flow was incompletely occluded. In a recent interview, Dr. Morgan stated, “We have seen signs of life in NRP when the brain has been reperfused,” which she found extremely disturbing. She called for a moratorium on NRP procedures until these concerns were addressed, but her request was ignored.
SUBSCRIBE TO OUR DAILY HEADLINES
Eventually, Dr. Morgan’s concerns did lead to the new recommendation that surgeons should slit and vent the blood vessels to the brain in addition to just clamping them. But Dr. Morgan says this advice is insufficient, as most surgeons already both clamp and slit the vessels going to the brain. “I honestly don’t believe they have created a policy that creates much or any more protection than these donors already had.”
Slitting the necks of NRP organ donors isn’t going to solve the real problem with NRP organ donation. The real problem is that NRP donors aren’t dead! The fact that these donors can still be resuscitated shows that they are still alive. NRP violates the dead donor rule and removes organs from living people.
In an interview with National Public Radio reporter Rob Stein, University of Rochester bioethicist Dr. Lainie Friedman Ross said:
“In order to be dead by circulatory criteria it means we’re not going to attempt to reestablish circulation. But that’s exactly what they do in NRP. So, yes, I have a real problem with NRP. I think it violates the dead donor rule. It’s taking organs from people who are no longer dead.”
The fact that the U.S. transplant system has continued to promote NRP organ procurement despite multiple medical, ethical, and legal concerns shows a grave lack of respect for people registering in good faith to become organ donors. NRP donors are not dead at the time that their organs are procured.
The Health Resources and Services Administration (HRSA) has invited the public to submit comments about this policy proposal from November 13 through December 28, 2026. Your politely worded comment about the fact that NRP organ donation violates the dead donor rule and puts people at risk of awareness during the removal of their organs can be submitted here.
